For nearly three decades, physicists have struggled to explain dark energy, the mysterious component that drives the universe’s accelerating expansion. It accounts for about 70 percent of the universe’s total energy density, but its physical origin is still unknown.
Most explanations introduce hypothetical particles or fields that have never been discovered. Now, however, researchers at the University of British Columbia (UBC) and the University of Sheffield have proposed an unexpected alternative.
Their latest study suggests that dark energy may come from the quantum physics of the force that holds atomic nuclei together. “Our theoretical framework suggests that new particles may not be required at all,” said Ariel Zhitnitsky, one of the study authors and a professor of physics and astronomy at UBC.
A known force could explain dark energy
The focus of the proposal is quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the established theory describing the strong nuclear force. This force connects tiny particles called quarks to form protons and neutrons, the building blocks of atomic nuclei.
QCD also describes the quantum vacuum, which is not a truly empty space. It contains quantum fields and energy, as well as complex properties that can influence how particles interact. One of these properties is called topology and describes the different possible configurations of the quantum vacuum.
The researchers suggest that the vacuum can exist in different topological configurations, with quantum tunneling allowing it to move between them. These processes contribute to the energy of the vacuum. Crucially, this contribution can change as the universe expands.
In ordinary flat spacetime, the QCD vacuum has a certain energy. However, the researchers suspect that its topological structure reacts differently in an expanding universe. This creates a small difference in vacuum energy that could drive cosmic acceleration.
“The characteristic energy scale predicted from the QCD vacuum and gravity is close to the dark energy scale observed today, without the need to introduce an ad hoc field or a new parameter,” Zhitnitsky said.
This suggests that the observed strength of dark energy may result from established physical constants and does not require an entirely new basic ingredient.
However, there is an important difference between the underlying physics and its cosmological implementation. Although the proposed mechanism does not require new fundamental particles or fields, the researchers’ model uses two additional parameters to describe when its contribution to dark energy becomes significant and how gradually it evolves.
Does the idea match what astronomers see?
A promising theory must also explain what telescopes observe. To test their proposal, the researchers compared its predictions with measurements of distant Type Ia supernovae, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), patterns in the distribution of galaxies that help scientists track the expansion of the universe.
The analysis included observations from the Planck, Atacama Cosmology Telescope and South Pole Telescope experiments, as well as measurements from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI).
For supernova data, the researchers tested two alternative datasets: Pantheon+ and the recalibrated Dark Energy Survey sample, known as DES-Dovekie. The researchers compared its framework to the standard Lambda CDM model, which treats dark energy as a constant, and another model that allows dark energy to change over time.
The QCD-based model showed comparable performance to Lambda-CDM when early or late universe observations were considered separately. However, combining measurements from both time periods resulted in it being slightly to moderately preferable in the researchers’ Bayesian comparison.
The results suggest that the framework could reproduce the evolving behavior of dark energy indicated by recent DESI observations, while providing a possible explanation for the physical origin of dark energy rather than simply describing its effects.
“The idea that the quantum vacuum, as described by QCD, could have the right properties to explain the accelerating expansion of the universe is very intriguing,” said Dong Ha Lee, lead author of the study and a doctoral student at the University of Sheffield.
What this means for physics
If confirmed, the proposal could provide an unexpected connection between the physics of atomic nuclei and the cosmological model that describes the universe. It could also provide a way to explain dark energy using established particle physics, rather than introducing entirely new fundamental ingredients.
However, consistent observations do not prove that QCD is responsible for dark energy. The mechanism needs even more theoretical support, especially a better understanding of how the quantum vacuum behaves as space-time expands.
The researchers plan to refine their calculations and test the framework against future astronomical observations to determine whether this well-known nuclear force really plays a cosmic role.
The study is published in The Astrophysical Journal.